Vista Video Editing

by Terry 8/12/2008 1:28:00 PM

I played with video editing last night, building a DVD for a fellow martial artist. Michelle is a Black Belt candidate at DMW Martial Arts. Among the requirements for getting your black belt is providing video documentation of forms, sparring skills, self defense and board breaks. Two reasons for this are to demonstrate proficiency of basic skills and create a visual record to review and look for improvement.

I am not skilled at editing video; I just use what I have. It is not great, but it works. Sort of.

I recorded the video on my hand-held JVC Everio GZ-MG37U recorder. It has a built-in 30 GB hard disk which stores a wee more than 7 hours of 720i HD video. I can plug the camera into my home computer’s USB port and transfer the files and away I go.

The JVC camera records video into an MPEG-2 derivative file format with a .MOB extension. I never really understood why it uses that format. Renaming the file will allow it to play in many players that do not recognize the .MOB extension. However, the files also do not have the correct 16:9 aspect ratio and instead play in an 4:3 aspect ratio, giving the video a squeezed appearance. That was an irritant until my friend Steve told me about SDCopy. SDCopy is a simple utility with basically one useful function; it copies the .MOB files to .MPG files and simultaneously sets the bit-flag on the destination file to indicate it is in wide-screen format.

With the files all coped to an .MPG format with the correct aspect ratio, I opened Microsoft Movie Maker on my Vista PC. I have mixed feelings about Vista. I am frankly disappointed with Microsoft about Vista. But that is another topic. Movie Maker, however, is a disappointment all its own. It works, but is it is not a great.

For what I need though, it works well enough. I have about 21 video clips to basically place titles on, and then make a DVD from it.

This is where it gets really odd to me. To make a DVD with Vista, you save your Movie Maker project and open the Vista DVD Maker. DVD Maker is about the most feature-poor DVD utility I have ever used. Oh, it works, but it does not offer much of anything. Why not include DVD Maker operations in Movie Maker? I mean, ‘Movie Maker’ implies it makes movies…

It is important to understand that DVD Maker is pretty feature poor at this point. My 21 video clips had to be saved into 21 Movie Maker project files for the DVD Maker process to work close to what I would hope. It took me about 45 minutes to same all the Movie Maker projects with the correct titles. Thankfully, I was not concerned much about editing. It was a fast process and I got into a routine of creating a project, inserting the clip, title the video and save the project – lather, rinse, repeat.

Then I open DVD Maker. I insert the 21 Movie Maker Projects and sorted them into my preferred play order. I spent a few minutes getting the menu options selected, saved the DVD project and told it to make the DVD. About forty minutes later I had a fresh new DVD and I am good to go. I just did not get what I expected; scenes.

Scenes are where the DVD video is divided into segments. Watch most any DVD movie and you will find a menu option on scene or chapter selection. DVD Maker takes each Movie Maker project as a separate scene, which is exactly the behavior I wanted; a simple menu to play the entire sequence as a single movie, and a scene selector to get to specific clips.

DVD Maker has no scene editing capabilities. You get what it gives you. It gives you about 18 scenes, maximum. Remember I have 21 scenes. DVD Maker essentially combines some clips together, retaining the detailed order, to give you 18 scenes. When I first looked at the DVD menu on my home DVD player I had a moment of fear thinking the video lost a few important clips. It turns out they are still there, but you have to select a scene before where you may be looking, then play that and skip ahead in the video.

Overall, for a quick and dirty bit of video production, it got the job done. The JVC Everio camcorder has grainy video when used under florescent lighting and my DVD has somewhat confused scene options, but the task is done. If I need to I can take it to the next level and fix it using other editors, although I do not know what I would use, perhaps a Mac. The JVC software I have is buggy but I may try that before I run out and buy a new workstation. Either way, Michelle has her video requirements complete.

Currently rated 1.4 by 28 people

  • Currently 1.428571/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Tags: , ,

computing | Martial Arts | Personal

Powered by BlogEngine.NET
Theme by Mads Kristensen

About Terry Losansky

Terry Dee Losansky

I am a software architect, actively practice and teach martial arts and live in Snoqualmie, Washington. I have an amazing daughter who is the jewel of my life.

E-mail me Send mail
Terry's Facebook profile


<<  July 2021  >>

View posts in large calendar

Recent comments



The opinions expressed herein are my own personal opinions and do not represent my employer's view in anyway.

© Copyright 2021

Sign in